Menu

Pagliai’s Pizza Menu

Pagliai’s Special
sm. - $13.65 med. - $17.80 lg. - $20.90
Our Original Thin Crust Pizza with Sausage, Beef, Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Onions
House Special
sm. - $11.05 med. - $14.80 lg. - $17.40
Our Original Thin Crust Pizza with Sausage, Onions, Green Peppers
Joe’s Special
sm. - $14.95 med. - $19.30 lg. - $22.65
Our Original Thin Crust Pizza with Sausage, Pepperoni, Extra Cheese, Onions, Canadian Bacon, Extra Sauce
Everything Pizza
sm. - $20.15 med. - $25.30 lg. - $29.35
Our 10 item special (Allow 30 Min. Cooking Time)
Big Red – Tomato Pizza
sm. - $14.95 med. - $19.15 lg. - $22.35
Thick Pan with Tomatoes & Triple Cheese (Allow 30 Min. Cooking Time)
Little Red – Tomato Pizza
sm. - $11.05 med. - $14.80 lg. - $17.40
Thin Pan with Tomatoes & Blend of Cheeses. Only Available in Thin Pan.
Signature Pepperoni Pizza
sm. - $11.05 med. - $14.80 lg. - $17.40
Our Original Thin Crust with Pepperoni and Special Blend of Cheeses. Only Available in Thin Pan.
BBQ Chicken Pizza
sm. - $9.75 med. - $13.30 lg. - $15.65
Our Original Thin Crust with BBQ Chicken
Chicken Fajita Pizza
sm. - $12.35 med. - $16.30 lg. - $19.15
Our Original Thin Crust with Chicken & Seasoned Grilled Vegetables
Chicken Ranch Pizza
sm. - $12.35 med. - $16.30 lg. - $19.15
Our Original Thin Crust with Savory Ranch Sauce, Chicken, Tomatoes & Bacon
Vegetarian Special #2
sm. - $13.65 med. - $17.80 lg. - $20.90
Our Original Thin Crust Pizza with Tomato, Spinach, Broccoli, Mushrooms
Vegetarian Special #1
sm. - $13.65 med. - $17.80 lg. - $20.90
Our Original Thin Crust Pizza with Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers, Black Olives
Create Your Own Pizza
sm. - $10.50 med. - $14.20 lg. - $16.60
Choose your crust (original or whole wheat) and delicious toppings to create your own pizza! Each Additional Ingredient: sm. $1.30, med. $1.50...
Lite & Healthy Pizza
sm. - $8.45 med. - $11.80 lg. - $13.90
Thin Crust. Choice of tomato sauce or olive oil sauce. Lite blend of cheeses and your choice of toppings. Baked crisp on brickovens. A true...
Single Ingredient Thick Pizza
sm. - $10.50 med. - $14.20 lg. - $16.60
Original or Whole Wheat Crust |  Available in Thick Crust Crisp or Thick Pan | Each Additional Ingredient: sm. $1.30, med. $1.50, lg. $1.75
Thick Cheese Pizza
sm. - $9.20 med. - $12.70 lg. - $14.85
A classic cheese pizza to satisfy your taste buds! Original or Whole Wheat Crust
Single Ingredient Thin Pizza
sm. - $9.75 med. - $13.30 lg. - $15.65
Original or Whole Wheat Crust |  Available in Thin Crust Crisp or Thin Pan | Each Additional Ingredient: sm. $1.30, med. $1.50, lg. $1.75
Cheese Pizza
sm. - $8.45 med. - $11.80 lg. - $13.90
A classic cheese pizza to satisfy your taste buds! Original or Whole Wheat Crust

Catering is available for inside dining, delivery and pickup.

Large Salad Bowl
In-House $25.00 To-Go $30.00
Serves 10-15 People. Includes bottle of dressing & silverware plate sets.
Small Salad Bowl
$15.00
Serves 6-8 People
Cavatelli (10″ x 13″ Pan)
$55.00
Includes Garlic Bread | Serves 8-10 People
Manicotti (10″ x 13″ Pan)
$55.00
Includes Garlic Bread | Serves 8-10 People
Lasagna (10″ x 13″ Pan)
$55.00
Includes Garlic Bread | Serves 8-10 People
Chicken Alfredo (10″ x 13″ Pan)
$55.00
Includes Garlic Bread | Serves 8-10 People
Fettuccini (10″ x 13″ Pan)
$50.00
Includes Garlic Bread | Serves 8-10 People
Mostaccioli (10″ x 13″ Pan)
$50.00
Includes Garlic Bread | Serves 8-10 People
Spaghetti (10″ x 13″ Pan)
$50.00
Includes Garlic Bread | Serves 8-10 People
Fettuccini Alfredo Dinner
Half - $8.45 Full - $9.75
All pastas are served with garlic bread.
Fettuccini Alfredo
Half - $7.00 Full - $8.25
All pastas are served with garlic bread.
Cavatelli Dinner
Full - $10.85
Small shell-like noodles with meat sauce, baked with layers of cheese. Dinners include pasta, garlic bread, and salad.
Cavatelli
Full - $9.35
Small shell-like noodles with meat sauce, baked with layers of cheese. All pastas are served with garlic bread.
Manicotti Dinner
Full - $10.85
Two large shells stuffed with three cheeses, with meat sauce. Dinners include pasta, garlic bread, and salad.
Manicotti
Full - $9.35
Two large shells stuffed with three cheeses, with meat sauce. All pastas are served with garlic bread.
Lasagna Dinner
Full - $11.35
Three layers of noodles, three cheeses, with meat sauce. Dinners include pasta, garlic bread, and salad.
Lasagna
Full - $9.85
All pastas are served with garlic bread.
Chicken Alfredo Dinner
Half - $10.05 Full - $11.35
Dinners include pasta, garlic bread, and salad.
Chicken Alfredo
Half - $8.60 Full - $9.85
All pastas are served with garlic bread.
Fettuccini Primavera Dinner
Half - $9.25 Full - $10.70
Dinners include pasta, garlic bread, and salad.
Fettuccini Primavera
Half - $7.75 Full - $9.20
All pastas are served with garlic bread.
Mostaccioli Dinner
Half - $7.90 Full - $9.20
Choice of meat sauce or marinara (meatless). Dinners include pasta, garlic bread, and salad.
Mostaccioli
Half - $6.60 Full - $7.65
Choice of meat sauce or marinara (meatless). All pastas are served with garlic bread.
Spaghetti Dinner
Half - $7.90 Full - $9.20
Choice of meat sauce or marinara (meatless). Dinners include pasta, garlic bread, and salad.
Spaghetti
Half - $6.60 Full - $7.65
Choice of meat sauce or marinara (meatless). All pastas are served with garlic bread.
Italian Beef
$5.99
All sandwiches include chips. | Extra Meat…..$1.99 | Add Cheese…..$0.95
Poorboy
$5.95
Ham, Salami, Cheese w/ French Dressing and Lettuce. All sandwiches include chips. | Extra Meat…..$1.99 | Add Cheese…..$0.95
Veggie Sandwich
$5.75
Mushroom, Onion, Black Olive, Green Pepper, Cheese | All sandwiches include chips. | Extras…..$1.99 | Add Cheese…..$0.95
Ham & Cheeese
$5.75
All sandwiches include chips. | Extra Meat…..$1.99 | Add Cheese…..$0.95
Meatball Sandwich
$5.99
All sandwiches include chips. | Extra Meat…..$1.99 | Add Cheese…..$0.95
Chocolate Torte (Gluten Free)
$5.95
A flourless chocolate cake with a chocolate ganache glaze over top.
Italian Cream (Slice)
$5.95
For any special occasion, this layered cake has hints of coconut and nuts with a smooth cream icing.
Tiramisu
$5.95
A popular coffee-flavored Italian custard dessert.
Chocolate Lovin Spoonful Cake
$5.95
Chocolate cake with thick layers of chocolate fudge filling.
Classic Cheesecake
$3.95
A crumbly graham cracker crust and silky cream cheese filling.
Turtle Cheesecake
$5.95
Cheesecake with chocolate-caramel drizzle.
Pagliai’s Sweet Vinaigrette Salad Dressing
Bottle $5.50
Our signature house dressing.
Dinner Salad
$3.15
Dressings: Italian, Ranch, Thousand Island, French, Creamy Italian, Poppy Seed, Blue Cheese, Pagliai’s own Sweet Vinaigrette (Fat Free)...
Italian Chef Salad
$7.99
Pepperoni, Onion, Canadian Bacon, Mozzarella Cheese, Black Olive with House Dressing, with Garlic Bread Dressings: Italian, Ranch, Thousand...
Chicken Wings
Half $6.50 Full $12.75
Available in Hot & Spicy
Garlic Cheese Sticks
12" w/Sauce $8.99 14" w/Sauce $9.99
Includes Marinara Sauce
Bread Sticks
$2.15
(2) Bread Sticks with Sauce
Pizza Bread
$3.50
Extra Toppings…..$0.95
Cheese Bread
$2.75
Toasted bread topped with cheese.
Garlic Bread
$1.50
Toasted bread topped with garlic and butter.
Sweet Tea
$1.95
Sprite Zero (Caffeine Free)
20 oz. Bottle $1.89
Sprite
Small $1.95 Large (Free Refills) $2.25 Pitchers $5.95 2-Liter $2.99
Pibb Extra
$1.95
Milk
$1.85
Lemonade
$1.95
Iced Tea
$1.85
Fanta Orange
20 oz. Bottle $1.89 2-Liter $2.99
Fanta Grape
20 oz. Bottle $1.89
Diet Coke
Small $1.95 Large (Free Refills) $2.25 Pitchers $5.95 2-Liter $2.99
Coke Zero
Small Fountain $1.95 20 oz. Bottle $1.89
Coke
Small $1.95 Large (Free Refills) $2.25 Pitchers $5.95 2-Liter $2.99
Coffee
$2.95

We also offer Import, Domestic, Craft and Local Beers & Wines

serving slices daily

Lunch (M-F): 11am – 4pm,
9pm – Close
Sat-Sun: 9pm – Close

We Offer

Delivery or Pickup

Please allow 25min. for pickups. 45min. – 1hr for deliveries. Times may increase when busy.

Read more

Gift Cards

We offer gift certificates in any amount. Perfect for that special occasion or celebration!

Read more

Events/Catering

Host your next party or business meeting in one of our party rooms. Reserve a room today!

Read more

Wine & Beer List

We have a generous assortment of local and imported wine & beer. A great compliment to your lunch or dinner!

Read more
TO TOP

We are currently closed, sorry for the inconvenience. Please check our store hours.